Using controller inside repeat, do I need a directive?

Question

Using controller inside repeat, do I need a directive?

When using a ng-repeat, how should I use a controller inside it?

For example, if I'm looping over a set of days in a week:

<ul ng-controller="WeekCtrl">
    <li ng-repeat="d in days">
        <span ng-controller="DayCtrl">
            {{dayOfWeek}} {{date}}: {{info}}
        </span>
    </li>
</ul>

But my DayCtrl wants to know what day d it is, so has to pull that out of the scope:

app.controller('DayCtrl', function($scope){
  $scope.date = $scope.d.date;
  $scope.dayOfWeek = 
    ['Mon','Tue','Wed','Thr','Fri','Sat','Sun']
    [$scope.d.date.getDay()];
  $scope.info = '... extra info...';
});

But this creates a dependency between the display and the controller. Ideally, I'd like to pass in d.date as an argument.

I could write a directive+controller and pass d.date in as an attribute. But that means I have to write a lot more and move the day's html into separate template, and I don't intend to use the DayCtrl elsewhere.

Alternatively, I could try and use <span ng-init="date=d.date"> but again, this feels dirty.

What's the right way of doing this.

Full example code on Plunker: http://plnkr.co/edit/wUxNFSEGjcDN7KlOLYdv which shows the problem I'm having with days and weeks.

angularjs

Answer 1

To me, this seems like a job for a directive, with d.date specified as an attribute.
I don't know how info is populated, but potentially your directive would not need a controller.

The day's HTML doesn't have to be in a separate/directive template, it can remain in the HTML:

 <li ng-repeat="d in days">
    <day date="d.date">
       {{dayOfWeek}} {{date}}: {{info}}
    </day>
 </li>

Directive:

app.directive('day', function() {
  return {
    restrict: 'E',
    scope: { date: '=' },
    link: function(scope) {
     scope.dayOfWeek =  ['Mon','Tue','Wed','Thr','Fri','Sat','Sun'][scope.date.getDay()];
     scope.info = '... extra info...';
    }
  };
});

Plunkr.

FYI, if you want to use ng-init, you can include it with the ng-controller:

<span ng-controller="DayCtrl" ng-init="date=d.date">